A Mother's Love
“Oh, careful, Betsy.”
My mother’s face grimaced in pain as I stood at the foot of her Medicaid recliner, her left foot resting on my right thigh, tugging at the support hose mandated at her last doctor visit. I whisked it off her foot and she winced again, sucking in her breath as if the extra air might cushion the pain. Gingerly, I grasped the top of the tightly bound flesh colored stocking on her right foot and pulled it off in one fluid motion. Mom’s breath caught in her throat, but only for a moment. She opened her eyes wide and smiled at me.
“My, but you are strong, aren’t you, Betsy Jeanne.”
I laughed and showed her my biceps, tensing so that they popped up in visible definition.
“Yep, Mom, those hours at the gym are beginning to pay off.”
“Oh God, Betty, I don’t know how you do it all…your practice, your boys, and then the gym, and the gardens and your writings. It exhausts me to even think of all the stuff you have going on, but still, here you are, taking care of me.”
“You know me, Mom, the more I have to do, the more I get done.” I glance at my watch. “Can’t stay, Mom, Kevin is home alone and even though I’m only a block away, I hate to leave him by himself.”
“I know that, sweetie. You go on, now.”
I slip the strap of my purse over my shoulder and head for the door.
“Betsy, could you….” Her voice trails off.
“Whacha need, Mom?” I look back from the door.
“Oh, I hate to be a bother. You go on.”
“Mom, if you need something, just tell me.”
She whimpers softly, “Oh, I hate to ask you. Could you just put some lotion on my right foot? It hurts soooo bad.”
I put my purse back down on the couch and resume my place at the foot of Mom’s recliner.
“Sure, Mom. This lotion?” I give the lotion dispenser two quick pushes and smooth the emollient onto her foot.
“Oooh, Oh, careful of the toes. Careful of the toes!”
I look down. Her toes are reddened and chafed, but I see no visible sores. I massage her foot gently, extra careful with her toes. She grimaces with each movement of my hands. She puts her head to one side and begins to cry softly.
“Oh, Betty, I’m afraid I’m gonna lose that foot. It hurts all the time. Something has to be wrong.”
I continue rubbing. There is no external evidence that anything is wrong with her feet. Her doctor has X-Rayed it on several occasions, finding nothing medically wrong.
“Where does it hurt, Mom?”
“All over, oh, it hurts so bad. The bottoms, especially. It feels like there is a fold in my skin and I’m walking on the fold.” She is whimpering softly, sniffling into a kleenex, head to one side, wiping the tears with her tissue.
I examine the bottoms of her feet. There does seem to be a crease down her right foot. Nothing out of the ordinary, nothing reddened, nothing obvious. But my mom is in pain, and I want to help. I massage her feet, help her get to bed, head home to get my son into bed next. As I walk, I think about the millisecond of anger that always rears its ugly head when my mother gets whimpery on me. I dearly love my mother, but her bouts of helplessness are like arrows buffeting the crusted sores around my childish heart. I don’t lash out, I suppress that anger quickly and decisively, tending to her needs, comforting her, getting her settled so I can leave. And then I think about it on my walk home.
It is no small irony that the road to my mother’s house is uphill, and the road back to home is down. My mother is an amazingly sweet woman. She is charming and compassionate, loves to tell stories, especially of when I was a little girl. She delights in learning people’s last names and then running a litany of people past the newcomer to determine whether or not they are remotely related to anyone in any of her past lives, particularly, the one she lived in Roanoke, Indiana, her hometown.
My children are gentle with her, always polite, checking in with her on their way to and from their various social functions. They take out her garbage and bring in her recycling bins without even being asked. I have to beg them to do those chores at home. They will sit with her and watch old movies, sneaking her popsicles and helping themselves to her Cheezits. She loves the company.
I idolized my mother when I was little. She was a nurse, working the night shift, 11-7. She was a vision of white, of compassion, of gentle good humor. She was always happy, always singing, always dozing in her chair. She wasn’t angry and unpredictable, like my father. One of my jobs was to polish her white nurse’s shoes and scrub the white shoe strings. I loved watching her get dressed for work in the evenings before bedtime, taking out the hairpins from the pin curls she set every afternoon, putting on her starched white nurse’s cap.
I sat on her lap regularly clear up to when I was sixteen, and felt the recliner groan under the weight of the two of us. She has been a large woman for most of the time I’ve known her, and her hugs have the cushions and padding that small children love and are comforted by. She is very generous with her affections. I have always felt loved.
It was not until I had children of my own that I discovered how angry with her I was. She moved in with Jeff and I, shortly after we bought our first house. It had four bedrooms and two baths. There was plenty of room for the three of us. She came to live with us with the understanding that after I had children, she would stay home with them so that I could go back to work. She had gone back to work six weeks after all five of her children had been born, regretting that she hadn’t had more time with them when they were small. She seemed to really enjoy caring for my oldest son when he was an infant.
She wasn’t the easiest person to live with. She is rather messy, and Jeff and I were both very tidy people. We were both constantly picking up after her, and I would hear about how it aggravated Jeff. Hell, it aggravated me, so at least we didn’t argue about it. She also had no sense of the privacy that relatively newly married people need. If we were watching television, there was mother. If we went out for dinner, her feelings would get hurt if we didn’t invite her along. Same with vacations. When she would go visit my siblings, those were the real vacations. But like I said, she was very loving, very sweet, very good natured, and her heart was always in the right place.
I had gone back to work full time a few months after having my second child. I spent my days trying to please men in stiff white shirts and navy blue pin stripe suits with coordinated silk ties. Men who had stay at home wives, who had no traces of regurgitated milk on the padded shoulders of their suits, as I seemed to always have. After Greg was about six months old, most days would find my mother in tears by the time I got home. She had always said that she would have given anything to stay home with her babies, and I figured I was giving her the next best thing. But she couldn’t handle it, couldn’t handle two children at the same time. My anger started to flare up at her regularly.
It took me a long time, and a lot of therapy to figure out why she was pissing me off so much. My mom was not cold and reserved, but she was perhaps even worse. She was helpless. She could not, or would not, protect me and my siblings from my asshole father. She was not strong enough to defy him, to risk incurring his wrath. She sacrificed her own daughters to protect her veneer of safety. When I had my own children, I discovered first hand the she bear nature that usually comes with giving birth. By offering her the opportunity to be the mother to my sons that she had been unable to be to me, I was offering her a chance to make amends, to make good on the cowardice she had shown when I was a child. Problem was, Mom was still the same weak person. Instead of being unable to stand up to my father, she was unable to stand up to my two year old. And it pissed me off.
I moved my mom out of my house and into her own apartment just after Greg’s first birthday. I found a reliable…and strong willed…caregiver to take her place. For the first few months after she left, I felt like I was on a permanent vacation. I still visited her regularly, and after awhile, we were able to get back to our familiar camaraderie, although something in our relationship had irrevocably changed. I had figured out that I had a choice to make. I could reject my mother because she was weak and didn’t protect me, or I could accept that my mother was what she was and would probably always be, and love her despite her weakness.
I chose the later.
It was not an easy choice.
A mother’s most instinctive job is to protect her children. I see it in birds, I see it in squirrels, when my cat had kittens, when my dog had puppies, hell, sometimes you even see it in insects. If my mother wasn’t able to function as a mother at the most instinctual level, what value could she give me as I tried to raise my children?
I figured out that I truly, intrinsically, loved my mother, as all children so desperately want to love their mothers, regardless of her strengths or weaknesses. I also figured out that my treatment of my mother, my interactions with her, and my children’s interactions with her, could be daily lessons in compassion and strength, for both them and for me. That was worth something.
I kissed my mother on the cheek, still wet from her tears, hiking my purse strap up on my shoulder and I prepared to leave a second time.
“I don’t know what I’d do without you, Betsy Jeanne. You are so good to me. Better than I deserve.”
That whimper was back in her voice. I had heard this litany before. I sighed.
“I love you, Mom.” That’s all I said.
“I love you, too, Betsy Jeanne.”
I know she does…as best she can.

