The big fish I caught two weeks ago is haunting me.
I lay in bed one night about a month ago and it occurred to me that I was safest from my father while he was alive and sick. I knew where he was and whether I saw him or not was up to me. I chose not to see him. As an adult, I saw him only seven times in thirty years, and never for more than an hour. Seven hours of my life in thirty years is all I could bring myself to share with him. Sometimes it was for only ten or fifteen minutes. Or less. I didn’t even talk to him at my uncle’s funeral.
I dated a guy once who told me I was being too hard on him, that I should forgive him, let him back into my life.
I dumped that guy.
Quickly.
Now that my father is dead…and has been dead for over a year, I wonder where his spirit lives…if there is a spirit world, of course. I’m not sure. I have faith, in something difficult to describe, but I have faith and trust that a force is out there to guide and protect. Of course, I wonder where that force was when I was a little girl, frightened and vulnerable, wetting my pants in fear of my father, so faith for me requires a certain suspension of disbelief, just like in the movies, or when reading a good book.
So there I am, thinking about the spirit of my father and suddenly, I’m just a little afraid. Not a lot afraid, just a little. I still feel stronger than my father, even in spirit form, and the part of me that allows a belief in spirits, insists that only the good part of a person is allowed to survive, only the good in my father is allowed to take spirit form.
Right?
I don’t think much more about it, but I ask my psychic friend what she thinks. She agrees that only the good survives, but gently smiles and tells me that even so, I’m still under no obligation to let him close, that I can still tell him to leave me alone. She says it’s up to me and I simply must ask my spirit guides to keep him away.
Two weeks ago, I took Kevin to my client’s farm down in central Kentucky. My client had invited 35 inner city kids to his farm to fish and frolic, and he invited me and my boys along as well. We got there late because Kevin had a soccer game and a baseball game. We were there for about an hour before all the inner city kids left.
My client had about 15 cane poles and dozens and dozens of nightcrawlers to use as bait to tempt the blue gills in his lake. I sat down with Kevin and we threw our bobbers and bait into the water. My client had enlisted a half dozen or so of his guy friends to help with the inner city kids, and one of them rushed to my aid when I started rummaging for a pole.
“Here, let me help you bait the hook.”
I looked at him. He was about ten years older than me, well dressed with khaki shorts and a polo shirt, leather boat shoes, clean shaven, thinning gray hair, wedding ring gleaming from his left hand. I smiled charmingly and let him bait my hook.
I’ve been fishing since I was three. My father was a fishing fanatic. Every vacation I took as a child involved fishing. He got me two presents my entire life. Ever. He bought me a bottle of L’Aire Du Temp perfume for my sixteenth birthday and a fishing pole of my own when I graduated from high school. My first means of earning money when I was a kid was to crawl around on soggy summer soil with a flashlight and pick nightcrawlers, which we sold for a penny a piece to my dad’s best friend who owned a bait shop. Nightcrawlers where nothing to me, baiting a hook was still as familiar to me as baking cookies, but still, I let the guy be a man and bait my hook…just that once. I did it myself the rest of the time.
I handed my cane pole with the nightcrawler squirming on the end to Kevin while I got a pole ready for him. While I skewered the nightcrawler on Kevin’s hook, the bobber from my pole disappeared under the water.
“Kevin! Pay attention, sweetie. Jerk the line to set the hook! You’ve got a fish!”
Kevin jerked the line wildly and the empty hook sailed out of the water and flew towards us.
“Careful Kevin. Fishing is an art. There’s a fine line between setting the hook and setting the fish free. If you keep your pole close to the edge of the water, you have more leverage. When it’s time to set the hook, one short, sharp pull will do it. Otherwise, you cue the fish, he lets go and your line flies up out of the water.”
I handed him a freshly baited pole, re-baited my pole and settled down next to my son. His bobber disappeared again. He quickly made a short, sharp jerk of his pole, and again, it came flying out of the water, empty hooked.
“Good job, Kevin. You were listening to me. Next time, count to three after the bobber disappears, but before you jerk the line. You don’t want to wait too long because you don’t want to give the fish time to swallow the hook, but you want to give the fish enough time to get the whole thing in his mouth so the hook has something to latch onto.”
Kevin looked at me warily. “This is boring, Mom.”
I sighed. I remembered so well sitting in a boat with my dad. Sitting and sitting, the morning still so early the mist wrapped us in moist. My dad always brought a thermos of coffee and a bread bag filled with sandwiches. His cigarettes would smoke out of his mouth as he gripped the butt with his yellowed teeth, eyes glittering with anticipation as he cast his lure. Fishing excited my father as almost nothing else did…well, except his prepubescent daughters.
I wasn’t allowed to talk while we were fishing. The only sounds were the birds, the water lapping at the edges of our boat, the insects humming, frogs splashing into the water as we passed close to the shore. That didn’t stop my father from screaming at me, from pulling my hair and calling me stupid when I missed a fish. It was ok for him to scream, but I couldn’t make a sound.
I would have never dreamed of voicing an opinion as to the value of the time spent in that boat with my dad, excruciating as the tedium was and I would have never dreamed of showing my fear. I smiled at my son’s comfort with expressing his displeasure with me.
“We won’t stay too long, sweetie. I don’t get the opportunity to fish very often, and I’d really like to enjoy this for a few minutes, ok? You don’t have to stay here with me if you don’t want to. You could go play on the swing if you wanted.”
“Nah, I’ll stay for a little while.”
His bobber disappeared and he gripped his pole, glancing up at me. I saw his lips move as he counted. He jerked up his pole and a medium sized blue gill wriggled at the end of his line.
“Kevin, you caught a fish!”
“Wow, I did, that was fun!”
“Do you want to try to get it off the hook or do you want me to?”
“You can do it, Mom.”
One of the guys had stood up and was headed towards us. “Here, let me do that.”
“No, actually, I’ve been fishing since I was three. I can handle this.” And I smoothed down the projecting sharp fins, gripping the fish with my left hand, deftly extracting the hook with my right.
“See Kevin, you have to be careful of these fins. They’re sharp. If you slide your hand gently down them, the fish won’t hurt you when you take the hook out.”
The guy watched me with my son. I glanced up and smiled. The guy shrugged his shoulders and headed off to find a beer.
“Look at this beautiful fish, Kevin.”
The fish gulped in quiet desperation, while I crooned to it. “Oh, you are a beauty, Mr. Fish. Your fins are strong and sleek, your scales a lovely iridescent blue. Thank you for entertaining us this afternoon.”
I tossed him back into the lake and for a moment, he hovered in the water at our feet, then darted off to recover under the safety of a rock.
“You don’t want to touch them any more than necessary, Kevin, because they have a protective film on their scales that prevents infections. If you touch them the slime comes off on your hands and when you throw them back in, it makes them vulnerable. I always admire my fish, thank my fish, then throw them back into the water as quickly as possible.”
“Do you like fishing, Mom?”
“I do. I don’t think I’d want to fish every day, but once in awhile is good for my soul for some reason.”
“Why is that?”
“Well, I guess I developed a love of gardening from working with my mom in her garden when I was a girl, and I guess I developed my love of nature from my father.”
“But I thought your father was not a nice man.”
“He wasn’t Kevin, but people are always a mix. No one is all bad, just as no one is all good.”
We fished for a while then, Kevin catching five blue gill, I caught three or four. One of the guys brought me a comfy chair to sit on, another guy brought me a beer. I smiled to myself at the thought of men waiting on me, a foreign concept to be sure, but I was the guest and they were playing host, so I decided to just enjoy it.
Suddenly, my pole arced and I stood up. I had something, something big.
“Hey, I think I’ve got a big one!”
My pole was almost bent in half and something was swimming wildly just off the pier. I started to inch my hands down the length of the cane pole.
My client rushed to my aid. “Here, Betty, let me help you!”
“No, really, I can do this!”
“Here, let’s get that fish up here on the dock!”
“Art, I can do this!”
Art pulled the line up, the large mouth bass dangling fitfully at the end. I snatched it from him, snaking the fingers of my left hand under the gills so that I could support the weight of the fish. With my right hand, I deftly freed my fish from the hook.
Art stepped back.
“You stay right there! Right there! I gotta get a picture of this!”
I was giddy with excitement. A beautiful 2 lb bass wriggled in protest from my left hand and Kevin peered silently at the biggest fish caught of the day.
“Hold it up higher, Betty!”
I grinned at the camera and proudly held up the fish, my other arm looped around Kevin’s neck, hoping the fish wouldn’t flop the wrong way and slap my face with its tail.
Kevin and I admired the fish for another minute, thanking it for entertaining us, then we tossed it back into the lake. Three boys came over and asked Kevin if he’d like to go swimming. He looked at me and I smiled my encouragement and off he went.
My client and two of his buddies were still fishing, so I sat back, tugged at the beer and re-baited my hook. I doubted if we would catch much more as the boys were splashing about thirty feet away to my left and the six month old puppies belonging to the son of my client were exploring the shoreline of the lake just a few feet the other way.
Half an hour went by. We caught a few more blue gills, the guy fishing across the lake hollered over at us that he had caught a catfish using chicken livers. I was enjoying the waning sun, the smells of the farm, the sounds of nature surrounding us. I felt something nibbling through the cane of my pole. I watched my bobber plummet, then resurface, plummet, then resurface again.
I stood up, tiptoeing to the edge of the dock. My bobber plunged deeper than a starlet’s neckline and my pole arced in half again. Suddenly I was struggling to maintain my grip on the cane pole. It was arcing left and right and out to the middle, then back towards the dock.
“Betty’s got another one!” One of the guys shouted and they all stood up to watch, but not a one of them made a move towards me. I think they were afraid I’d push them in the lake if they tried to help.
I shoved my cane pole all the way back behind me and slowly started pulling up the line with my hands. The fish was panicked, trying to find a way out of being extracted from the water. I was patient and gentle, cooing calmly to the fish the whole time, promising to set him free just as soon as I took out the hook and got a nice, long look at him. Holding him up with my right hand, the fishing line pressing deeply into my flesh, I slipped my fingers under his gill and hauled him up to show off. I whisked off the hook and took a good look at this beautiful fish.
Brilliantly green scales shimmered up at me, exquisitely detailed fins arched in protest, its tail fanned frantically as it fought my scrutiny.
“Betty, that fish has got to be at least 3 lbs. I think that is the biggest fish I’ve ever seen caught out of my lake.” Art stood before me with his camera. I raised up the fish and smiled at the flash.
“Do you want to keep it or should we let ‘er go?” My client queried.
“Oh, we’ll let her go, but from now on, whenever any one else catches her, I’m hoping you’ll call her Old Betty….like Walter in ‘On Golden Pond’.”
My client chuckled and nodded. “You got it, although I don’t know many women that would want their namesake to be a fish…and to be have “Old” tacked on, to boot.”
I thought about that fish while I sat there on the dock, watching the sun set, the lake calming to a smooth mirror. I was the only one to catch any bass that day. Me, who fishes maybe once a year. I wondered at the odds, and I thought of my father and how proud he would have been, how he would have loved to have been there, teaching his tricks to my twelve year old son, basking in the glory of watching me pull in those fish by hand.
The breeze picked up at that moment and I shivered in response.
Perhaps he had been there all along, guiding those fish to my pole, inviting me out to play, asking for a chance to reconnect.
Could I?
Could I ever?
I drove home in the dark, Kevin slumbering next to me, and my eyes brimmed with tears. I was a little ashamed of myself for refusing to let those men help me, for being so damned independent that I couldn’t give those men the pleasure of handling the nightcrawlers, and taking the fish off my hook. I had to do it myself. I had to show them how tough and accomplished I was, even at such a manly sport as fishing. I have to prove myself to every man I meet. No wonder I’m single, I chastised myself. What guy would want to compete?
I remembered then, why I am the way I am. I am fearless because I had to be. I am fearless because courage was my greatest resource in learning how to survive being a daughter of my father’s. He hated fear. He preyed on fear. He respected courage. Of course I couldn’t ever voice an opinion, but at least he didn’t beat me like he beat my sister.
I learned to be independent, to not trust anyone else to take care of me because of my father’s sick relationship with me. My father failed at a father’s primary job; to teach their daughters how to deal with men, and to teach their sons how to treat women. My father taught me to distrust men, to be careful, to be cautious, to never need anything, especially from a man.
Even worse, he taught me to equate sex with love. Every show of affection my father ever gave me was tainted with sexuality; a pat on the butt, a slip of the hand, a full on the mouth kiss. It makes me sick to my stomach to think about it. Every memory of my father that I have is laced with nausea. The only way my father knew how to love me, or my sisters, was sexual in nature. But that wasn’t love. That was sickness.
How do I unlearn this?
Six months of celibacy is a start.
And tossing back that fish was a good idea, too.
A part of me likes to think that if my father knew the consequences of his actions, if he knew that succumbing to his sick desires when we were little would cost him the pleasures of our company for the rest of his life, that he would have made a different choice. That requires thinking that he regretted his actions, and truthfully, I don’t think my father was capable of regret. It was always someone else’s fault.
My father justified his actions by insisting that he was “teaching” us, helping us to grow up. Now that I am a parent, I realize the horrendous gravity of his crimes. The actions we take with our children, good and bad, last them the rest of their lives. Those first twenty years imprint us. There are no rewinds or do overs from a childhood.
All there is, is live through and survive, and that’s a lesson I learned and learned well.
For where I am right now, I say to the spirit of my father, “No thanks, Dad. I don’t need your help. I can take it from here by myself.”
Like I always have.